Quotes of the Month
Archives
Summer 2009
In my last Webletter, I said that I wouldn't skip seasons. Well, I guess I lied for Spring went by without one. A lot has happened since the last publication. In my life and the lives of others; but, most importantly in this country-the good old USA. We have a new President who is faced with monumental problems, hopefully not insurmountable. In the face of a significant recession, he is attempting to repair America's Health System. I never thought I would say this, but I must admit that our once proud American Medical System is broken and needs a complete overhaul. I am convinced that before that can be accomplished, the cost of medicine in the USA must be significantly reduced. We spend more per capita than any other industrialized nation and have less value for the expense.
In the following text, I am going to outline some of the major causes for this exorbitant expenditure. Physicians drive medical care in this country and must give their full cooperation in striving for cost reduction.
- WASTE: I used to cringe in the operating room when I witnessed packages after packages of sutures opened by mistake and then discarded. Some hospitals salvaged these and sent them to third world countries for re-sterilization and subsequent use. Many other items which were disposable and opened by mistake were likewise wasted. This is just an example of the waste which goes on all over a hospital and is magnified by the same thing happening all over the country. The cost mounts up and is significant.
- DUPLICATION OF PROCEDURES: Time after time, I used to see tests unnecessarily repeated when patients were transferred to other institutions or referred to other doctors. Better communication and perhaps electronic record transfer could reduce this. The sad thing is that many times the other institution or physician gives a lame excuse and repeats the procedure so that they can reap the benefit.
- UNNECESSARY IMAGING: This could perhaps be under no. 2, but it is so large, I think it deserves a separate category. Billions of dollars are spent each year on MRIs, CT scans, and other imaging procedures. Some of these are not needed and others are duplicated unnecessarily. In some cases they are done on outdated or inferior equipment and must be repeated for adequate quality.
- MEDICARE READMISSIONS: A recent study demonstrated that this amounted to a significant sum of money. This should be correctable.
- MEDICAL CARE AT EITHER EXTREME OF LIFE: Premature babies by unwed mothers who do not seek prenatal care cost a significant amount of money to care for and then continue to drain medical resources and funds. The extreme elderly who are sent to ERs by nursing homes and family members and then are admitted to the Intensive Care Units only to expire just as they would have in a more serene setting, cost Medicare billions of dollars each year.
- INAPPROPRIATE EMERGENCY ROOM CARE: Too often patients go to the ER for problems which could have been handled just as well or better in a doctor's office. It is sad to say that this is not always the patient's decision. For instance, this horror story just recently came to my attention. My former Internist and good friend who is now retired told me of a situation which he was involved with. A good friend who suffered from chronic congestive heart failure contacted him because her son was out of the city and she was having an exacerbation of her problem. My friend, the doctor, took her to her cardiologist's office. That group was one of the largest and supposedly respected cardiologists in the city. Her cardiologist was not in the office, so his nurse saw the patient and suggested that she go to the ER. My friend asked the nurse if one of the other cardiologists could see her (there were 5 there that day). She said for some reason that would not be possible. So they went to the nearby ER and proceeded to wait hours for attention. Finally, the ER doc saw her and said yes, she needed to see a cardiologist. A call went in to her cardiologist and they waited longer. In the mean time, my friend kept calling back to the office trying to talk to one of the cardiologists. When the patient's cardiologist finally got to the ER, he proceeded to "chew out" my friend for disrupting his office. He treated the patient and sent her home. Her purse and Medicare's wallet was much lighter as a result. Besides the unnecessary additional expense, I ask you; Was this good medicine? No, it most certainly wasn't! Unfortunately, this scenario is currently not unusual and this is one of the many things wrong with American Medicine today.
I'm sure there are many other reasons for the excessive cost of American medicine. These are just some that are evident to me. Another reason for the excessive cost, and this one will be the most difficult to remedy, is specialty remuneration, for the most part is procedure driven. In other words, the more procedures done, the more the specialist receives. As Medicare relentlessly lowers the remuneration per procedure, the more procedures must be done to keep up the total income. This is necessary because there is no cap on the physician's overhead and this has continued to escalate. I'm not saying that these procedures are done unnecessarily, but unfortunately, there are always some spoiled apples in the barrel. How much that amounts to, I have no way of knowing.
What's the answer to this conundrum? I wish that I had the answer. I know it's going to be difficult, for correction of many of the previously outlined problems will require a completely different medical delivery system by American Physicians.
How about major hospitals establishing complete medical delivery systems with salaried specialists and affiliated outpatient primary care clinics geographically oriented around the hospital. Sort of multiple Mayo Clinics. The Medical Insurance Companies, private or government subsidized, would then contract with various centers according to location. It's just a thought, off the top of my head, and one that I never thought I would ever make. Maybe being retired has something to do with it. I know it would be a hard sell to the medical profession.
OTHER NEWS
I am currently working on a sequel to Hello My Name Is Tiff. In this book Tiff will come to earth as a Guardian Angel to help a compromised dog get through the Westminster Dog Show. The original book is still for sale at Xlibris.
Book Orders Dept. Money order, check,or credit card
Xlibris Corp.
International Plaza II, Ste, 340
Philadelphia, PA 19113
All previous items listed are still for sale and at same price. In addition, I recently aquired an Odilon Redon lithograph. Et celui qui etait monte dessus se nommait la Mort (Mellario 176) 1899 from the suite Apocalypse de Saint-Jean, edition/100. Price $2000.
THOUGHTS FOR THE QUARTER
Medicine is like a woman who changes with the fashions.
- August Bier (1861-1949)
Nature, time, and patience are the three great physicians.
- Bulgarian proverb
Medicine can only cure curable diseases, and then not always.
- Chinese proverb
If every man would mend a man, then all the world would be mended.
- Anonymous
Take care until next time, Robert J. Turner, III, M.D., F.A.C.S. Editor
To ask questions or submit comments, please fill out and submit the contact form.
ARCHIVES
Winter 2008
Summer 2006
Summer 2005 - Lung Cancer
Spring 2005 - Preventive Medicine
Winter 2005 - Medical Pearls
Fall 2004 - Women's Health
Summer Trip to Russia
Miscellaneous Medical One Liners
Trip to Ireland
Texas Surgical Society Meeting Notes
The Malpractice Crisis
Treatment and Prevention of Malignant Disease
|